By Joseph Catena
You probably didn’t listen to me, but I was really on the money about Election Day.
I told you that Susan Collins would beat Kissin’ Cousin Troy Jackson and retain her U.S. Senate seat in Maine. I was confident that Ken Paxton would keep Texas red and fend off the anti-Christian Christian James Talarico. And I was uber confident that the good people of Michigan would elect Mike Rogers over de facto terrorist representative Abdul El-Sayed. I also thought the GOP would retain the Senate by a slim majority – even a 50-50 split was a win since Vice President J.D. Vance would be the tiebreaking vote.
Of course, I couldn’t be more wrong about any of this as the Democrats scored historic wins everywhere and redesigned the U.S. electoral map. For now. So, where the heck was I right? I told you there was no such thing as a political expert, most of all, yours truly. Sure, the polls indicated the Senate races were close, many of them tossups, but did anyone see the Democrats flipping nine seats? To give credit, there were many polls that showed them possibly winning four to five seats and flipping the Senate by a slim margin, and just about everyone had the House of Representatives turning blue.
Republicans took a historic walloping that will go alongside the Gingrich Revolution in ’94, the Tea Party Revolt in 2010. It was ugly, and right now, conservatives and MAGA forces alike must endure some excruciating political pain. Democrats and socialists have claimed the power at the moment, and the fight will continue, especially when the good guys cede power in just a few weeks. Now that election fever has cooled, we can analyze the results with clear heads and no hysteria. There were numerous factors that are attributed to the GOP whipping. Some hold more relevance than others.
Lawler’s Come to ‘Jesus’ Moment
Outgoing N.Y. Rep. Mike Lawler lost his seat to Democrat Cait Conley by about six points. Lawler’s was considered one of many major battleground seats. While he embraced President Trump’s support and agenda, Lawler also showed to be tough when needed. He was relentless in lobbying the president to raise the federal State and Local Tax (SALT) deduction cap from $10,000 to $40,000 in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act in order for him to vote for the bill. He ran a tough campaign and hit Conley hard as an out-of-touch liberal, who was a progressive, especially on taxes and immigration. But even a polished, independent-minded official like Lawler could not overcome the typhoon.
Lawler summed up the GOP misfortunes and his own demise by stating: “Jesus Christ could have run and would have lost.”

I don’t think so, Mike. No election is bigger than Christ.
If Jesus ran against Talarico, he would have won about 91% of the vote, maybe more. The 9% of Texans who identify as agnostic and atheist may have sat this one out or voted third party. Imagine a debate between Christ and Talarico if the latter was pressed on his “biblical” pro-abortion views when he invoked the Blessed Virgin Mary, saying that it was her choice and she gave the OK to God the Father Almighty to plant the seed of Christ in her body in the Immaculate Conception.
Jesus would have probably had a mic drop moment in a very Christian manner.
“I beg your pardon, James, but I know my parents far better than you. And trust me my son, Father wore the pants in this relationship, and Mom had no say so on whether or not they would start a family! You do remember Dad’s grand plan and what I was put through at the end, don’t you?”
Christ would have also won Michigan with ease against El-Sayed, his antithesis. It is conceivable, however, that Jesus might have been given a run for his money in Dearborn. El-Sayed’s arrogance and horrific demeanor would have been a stark contrast to the Lord and Savior. Had he spewed his infamous “I am a F—in’ wolverine!” line at a pro-El-Sayed/anti-Christ rally, Jesus would have calmly replied, “And I am Jesus, a Semite from Israel. I turn Jew-hating wolverines like you into passive little kittens.”
The mic drop would have thundered so hard that Michigan might have cracked off the map and floated aimlessly into the Great Lakes.
Lawler’s overstatement holds truth in the sense that the holding pattern in Iran and higher gas and food prices made it difficult for anyone with an “R” next to their name to win. Timing was terrible and the numerous accomplishments Trump and the Republicans had up until the Iran war were all lost. Short memories by the voters and extremely weak messaging by Republicans added to the toxic mix.
Candidates and campaigns matter
I am sure Ken Paxton would have been a great vote to have in the Senate, as would Darline Graham, and Michael Whatley. But let’s face it, they were pathetic candidates. Forget Paxton’s marital and moral shortcomings and his choices of whom he partied with on New Year’s Eve (Bill Clinton was far worse). Paxton couldn’t light a fire under the voters’ derrieres, even if he had a gas can and an acetylene torch. The man was boring, had less energy than Jeb Bush, and his only message was how weird Talarico was, as if we didn’t already know. The charismatically challenged Texan should have focused on his wonderful record when he served as the Lone Star State’s attorney general, and what types of innovative legislation he would support to address the affordability factor. Paxton should retire for good from politics and take Trump’s advice on improving his wardrobe. If he does decide to ever run again, someone needs to prescribe him some political Viagra. That and a few good suits could do the trick.
Who’s kidding who? It still won’t help.
Graham should have respectfully refused Trump’s demand that she succeed her late brother in South Carolina, another Republican haven. She had no experience, admitted she didn’t know much about politics, and had no gravitas. A nice lady who, like the wooden Paxton, would have undoubtedly voted the right way if elected, but she had no business playing in this high-stakes game. A total dud.
As for Whatley, he was a wonderful national co-chair in 2024 and deserves kudos for helping Trump get elected for a second time. But his candidacy was flat, and he was no match for Roy Cooper, a savvy old dog who knew how to reach his constituency and win an election. Whatley was flat. While no one was a dull as Paxton, Whatley certainly didn’t show the ability to energize the base. Would love to have had his vote in the Senate, but wow was he a bad candidate.
Is MAGA finished?
This is more complicated than a quick yes or no answer. Remember, Trump still has two years to go. He will have to lead by executive order and veto if the Democrats decide to come at him with insane socialist policies. While Republicans are limited in number in both houses, it doesn’t mean that Trump’s policies are unpopular. Voters still want a safe border, tax cuts and keeping the same biological sexes in their own sports, locker rooms and bathrooms. Incidentally, it’s a pretty safe bet that Christ would certainly approve of that last one.
In many ways, MAGA is an extension of the Tea Party movement, which was spawned in 2009 as a repudiation of President Barack Obama’s overreaches with what they saw as government overreach on taxes, government healthcare, liberal Supreme Court justices, and better border control. So even if the label fades, the ideology won’t.
Right now, President Trump is feeling the brunt of the midterm brutalization. His next two years will be pivotal to his movement. Remember, many of the newly elected Democrats in both chambers ran away from crazy woke ideology and stuck to those ever-important kitchen table issues. Perhaps the president can find a way to strike some acceptable deals with them. If the majority decides to act insane, Trump will have to expose them by using his veto power and lead by executive order. Still, the president has two years to go. Before the opposition storms in, Trump would be wise to declare victory in Iran, maintain the sanctions, and continue controlling the Strait of Hormuz. He should also tweak some of the tariffs and try to strike one last impactful deal before January. This way, the otherwise strong economy will continue to flourish, and gas will continue to drop at a steady rate. By January, he will have some leverage and serve as a reminder to the public that he has been historically consequential.
And if a self-described non-political expert like myself sees this, so should the powers that be.